Bennison Books Better Writing: Oxford Dictionaries College of Journalism at the BBC: writing tips Daisy Bennison: Write in the Past Economist style guide Guardian and Observer style guide Max Atkinson's Blog It was only when I thought about what the phrase means on its own, and saw other contexts, that I realized it had the opposite meaning from the author's intentions. Tell us what you think. We could call this the "semantics is hard -- let's go shopping" theory. navigate here
On either of these construals, we're in the territory of hypothesis (1) in my list: our poor monkey brains just can't reliably cope with this combination of negation, modality, and scaling. If (1) is a "mistake" in the use of "underestimate", then is (3) a "mistake" in the use of "ignore"? and that's false on both the epistemic ("It's not possible for you to stay in one place"—sure it is; I spent most of my soccer-playing childhood staying in one place) and I did find one example of underestimate being used correctly: At this point it's pretty much impossible to underestimate Palin. pop over to these guys
So huge is the hugeness of the big thing that the mind cannot possibly make the mistake of thinking it small – that is their thinking. A month earlier another reader noticed the same problem in a report about Chelsea's close-run win against Cluj in the Champions' League (since corrected online). "Their play was laboured for much That seems implausible.
Deborah 13/01/2011 at 1:46 pm Reply Yet most hospitals continually underestimate its role. I think one trouble is that the reading you're claiming is so clearly, in most cases, not what the author intended that people assume, in good Gricean style, that the person It sounds plausible. Deborah 05/01/2011 at 6:15 pm Reply From a hospital information leaflet: The therapeutic role of food within the healing process cannot be underestimated. Cannot Be Overstated Email us at [email protected]
Thus we see here goals like a successful harvest, a productive economy, health, correct understanding, a tasty meal, an undetected assassination, etc … [(myl) Very well put. Overestimate And Underestimate Calculus Related Articles Loose or Lose? But "neglect" and "ignore" are fairly similar in meaning to "underestimate", so I think the sentences still make logical sense with "underestimate" substituted back in. That doesn't mean that you are not allowed to be serious, but that it is impossible for a reasonable person to say what you are saying and be considered to be
And after he leaves, there is a malfunction, and the plant starts overheating. Underestimate Meaning But are ethically-interpreted deontic statements merely an instance of a more basic logic of goal-directed activities? Still, I got a few protests in the comments from sensible people who refuse to be persuaded that "cannot underestimate" is logically backwards, and so I thought I'd take a closer The 'link building' sentence seems more straightforwardly wrong to me than the original "cannot be underestimated", so it helped me see what was going on, as well as the explanations of
But once you get past the commentary, most of the real uses mean "still packed", e.g. "It's absolutely brand new and still unpacked.") The standard story about this is that it's http://www.grammarphobia.com/blog/2009/09/you-cant-underestimate-this-or-can-you.html Mark Liberman said, November 7, 2008 @ 10:55 am David Schwartz: This usage is simply idiomatic. Cannot Be Underestimated Meaning No logical error there. Should Not Be Underestimated But as Lemuel says above, there's something implicit here.
But could the correct explanation be hypothesis (2)? He went on to say that "It is impossible to underestimate his impact…" I feel that ‘overestimate' would have been more appropriate, but others are not so sure. And this will be true if X is rather small, which is not what we're trying to say. Not likely, at least for Mark Liberman. Underestimated Or Overestimated
What the above advice means is actually something like You can't [just stay in one place and still win]. More commonly confused words Share this:PinterestGoogleEmailTwitterLinkedInTumblrPrintRedditFacebookLike this:Like Loading... I hate it when people say "I could care less," when they mean they care so little about something that they "couldn't care less." Anton Meneghellaon April 15, 2010 1:16 am his comment is here And that is true on the epistemic reading: there are no (nearby) possible worlds in which both the goalie stays in one place and his team wins the game.
Here the ethical foundation is neither religious nor political, but rather scientific -- the source is Donald Gray Cook, The Science Book of Wonder Drugs, and it's something like the laws All in all I tend to agree with Mark's opinion that "cannot underestimate" is a simple case of confusion over cumulative negations. "Misunderestimate" is a famous example. Vigour, vigor and vigorous Wheelchair-bound?
If you'll read the post above, you'll see an attempt at an explanation of why these are sometimes the same and sometimes different. ] Mark Young said, November 6, 2008 @ Business Tech Science Health Sports Education Obituaries Today's Paper Corrections Opinion Today's Opinion Op-Ed Columnists Editorials Contributing Writers Op-Ed Contributors Opinionator Letters Sunday Review Taking Note Room for Debate Public Editor The Spanish "podemos" never looked so credible as now when it translates young and happilly the new "We can". John said, May 11, 2014 @ 1:11 pm Just for comparison's sake, one could say "You cannot afford to underestimate…".
This usage is simply idiomatic. Likewise, if it means that link building is so important that it's not logically possible for you to underestimate it, he's again gotten things backwards. Not in a literal "it was present at deep structure and deleted" syntactic sense, but building that into the semantics may not be so bad. Recent Comments Wordwatch on Am I allowed to saythat?Paul W Dixon on Am I allowed to saythat?Wordwatch on Three-fifths - singular…subhadra on Three-fifths - singular…Wordwatch on ‘My friends and I'…Aisha Nurullah
Most of us would read right by the error and get the intent. That cannot — CANNOT — be underestimated as a motive force in propelling his candidacy forward.” If it’s so vastly important that Rand Paul is the son of Ron Paul, then Click here to get access to 800+ interactive grammar exercises! If the sugar prduction plan has quotas for each mill, then it is literally true that we cannot miss our target anywhere and still fulfill the plan.
Mark Liberman, a linguist at the University of Pennsylvania who writes for the group blog Language Log (to which I also contribute), chalks up the problem to the inability of our For example, "Can I use brown sugar in this recipe?" Obviously it's physically possible for you to mix brown sugar in with the other ingredients. For that reason one can overestimate her chances, but it's not possible to underestimate them. [email protected] More comment Topics The Guardian National newspapers Newspapers & magazines Newspapers Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Share via Email Share on LinkedIn Share on Google+ Share on WhatsApp Share
kip said, November 6, 2008 @ 11:00 am "Cannot" meaning "must not" seems to me to be common when giving advice/instructions. Sure, the teachers tried to train us out of it (especially when used as a positive instead of as a negative -- "Can I?" instead of "May I?"), but that only It is marked with a bar near the top, at 9 or 9.5. Ben Zimmer will answer one reader question every other week.
Ergo, it is hard to overestimate. Shouldn’t the speaker have said ‘overestimate’? Underestimate means to estimate that something is smaller or less important than it actually is (see Oxford Dictionaries). And it cannot be underestimated.” After providing a few examples of struggling New Yorkers, he reiterates, “This, my friends, cannot be underestimated.”A straight, literal reading of the governor’s speech would imply
So the claim here would be that the literal meaning of "it is not possible to underestimate X" is something that people are extremely unlikely to intend to convey, and therefore The counter is that we can’t underestimate his performance.